Zuber's has been sold and is now closed as of August 25, 2025.
Recipes: Heavenly Coconut Cake

January 30, 2022 | Recipes

Heavenly Coconut Cake

Yellow cake mix
1 can Eagle Brand sweetened condensed milk
6 oz. flaked coconut
8 oz. Cool Whip
6 oz. crème of coconut (it is non-alcoholic, but buy it at the store among mixes for mixed drinks)

Bake yellow cake. Soon as you pull out from oven, take wooden spoon handle and poke many holes in top of cake. Pour Eagle Brand milk in holes. Let cake cool. Mix coconut, Cool Whip and crème of coconut; spread on cooled cake and refrigerate.

Sheryl Bull


This recipe comes from the West Liberty Sesquicentennial Cookbook and is used with permission.

More Posts

Brian and Bonnie on their first day at Zuber's

Zuber’s is Closing on August 25

Front Desk

Phone Number Alternative

antique lantern in the Zuber's Wagon Wheel Room

Treasures Tell Stories! Antiques, Arts, and Quilts